What if there were a run on a bank and no one knew? In recent days, some U.S. media have focused on a “silent run” on the deposits of Wachovia bank, which is now being taken over, after a bailout plan stalled and its rival Washington Mutual was seized.
Commentators including Nouriel Roubini, professor of economics at New York University’s Stern School of Business, have highlighted the scope for quiet withdrawals by depositors whose assets exceed guaranteed levels.
But in Europe, another high-profile banking failure has drawn attention to a different 21st-century phenomenon: As homes and businesses increasingly manage their finances online, mass withdrawals may be invisible.
Fortis, focus of a cross-border rescue last week, was also in part the victim of a silent bank run, which along with a dramatic fall in its stock prompted Benelux governments to step in and inject cash into the banking and insurance group.
“If Fortis were in trouble, I would transfer my money over the Internet to my parents’ account,” student Frederique Schilte said outside an Amsterdam branch, where she had gone to drop off a bill payment.
In the Great Depression between 1929 and 1933, much of the damage was caused by runs on banks that gained momentum as people saw lines of customers waiting to salvage cash. In Fortis’s case, much of the outflow came at the click of a mouse.
Fortis said it had lost about 3 percent of its deposits since the beginning of this year, both from consumer and business clients, or about $7 billion in euros.
Dutch Finance Minister Wouter Bos noted Fortis had trouble keeping corporate clients and was faced with “increasing liquidity problems in the banking activities.”
“Big amounts were withdrawn by private and business clients, particularly in Belgium,” said Tilburg University professor Sylvester Eijffinger, who is also an economic policy adviser to the Dutch parliament. “The capital supplied [by Benelux governments] was gone and they had to act quickly.”
The intervention seemed this week to have worked.
“We were worried last week, but now that it is now part of the Dutch government, we are staying with Fortis,” said a Dutch customer who declined to give her name but said she and her husband have been Fortis customers for 28 years.
Speed and volume
Britain’s Northern Rock, which last September suffered the first run on the deposits of a major British bank for more than 140 years, saw customers line up over three days at branches when confidence evaporated, creating scenes that one politician said made Britain looked like “a banana republic.”
But branch withdrawals slowed after the government guaranteed savings. The major damage was done by withdrawals by Internet, postal and telephone customers. Almost $25 billion of savings were withdrawn from Northern Rock from the start of the panic until the end of 2007, more than half its retail deposits.
About one-third of the cash pulled out was at branches, but the remaining two-thirds, or almost $17.6 billion, was taken out by non-branch customers.
Whether visible or not, the psychology is the same: Barbara Williams, a retired customer of Northern Rock, was one of hundreds who stood in line outside its branches last year.
“I didn’t initially panic but the more you watch the news and read you think maybe we ought to do it as well,” she told Reuters at the time. “We thought we would do what everyone else is doing. Rightly or wrongly it’s a chance you can’t take.”
The online run may spare banks the damage of customers flooding branches to pull out cash: but funds can be moved even quicker and in far larger quantities with the click of a mouse or a telephone call.
This is one of the concerns behind recent scrambles by governments in Europe to increase depositor sums under guarantee. Ireland and Denmark have offered blanket guarantees to savers, and pressure is mounting on others to follow.
Ironically, it was another Dutch bank, ING, that pioneered the growth of online banking by launching ING Direct over a decade ago: amassing $261.5 billion in savings and current account deposits, it is now the world’s 12th largest.
ING Direct operates without physical branches; customers open and manage their accounts via the phone or Web. It is not active in its home markets because of its existing retail network, and has instead built a business network in North America, Europe and Australia.
Banks have always lent more than their clients hold on deposit, leaving the risk that none would have enough cash to pay out if they all turned up at once. Back in the 1930s, depositors faced losing all their money if a bank collapsed.
Attilio Vianello, now 98, remembers how in the 1930s he had just started a job at Credito Veneto, a small bank based in Padoa, Italy, as the crisis spread beyond Wall Street to Europe.
“Banks were going bust from one day to another and the vast majority of people did not manage to rescue their savings because once they knew, it was too late. They would find the doors already shut,” he recalled.
The electronic equivalent of this would be a server failure, or a Web site shutdown. But executives point out that in any silent run — made possible by electronic money transfer whether through the Internet or wholesale networks — the most damaging aspect is the speed at which business customers can move.
“The so-called silent run on the bank — it’s real,” Carlos Evans, Wachovia’s (NYSE: WB) wholesale banking executive, was quoted as saying in the Kansas City Star newspaper. He said withdrawals started picking up on Sept. 26 and over subsequent days.
“You go from being weakened to in trouble in a matter of days. I don’t think people understand how quickly events unfolded,” he said.
Confidence can return, but often only after dramatic state intervention. Now state-owned, Northern Rock recently had to close to new savers after attracting about $10.5 billion this year from customers drawn by government guarantees.
Copyright 2007 Reuters. Click for restrictions.
Huawei’s AI Update: Things Are Moving Faster Than We Think
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
December 04, 2020
Keeping Machine Learning Algorithms Honest in the ‘Ethics-First’ Era
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Guest Author,
November 18, 2020
Key Trends in Chatbots and RPA
FEATURE | By Guest Author,
November 10, 2020
FEATURE | By Samuel Greengard,
November 05, 2020
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Guest Author,
November 02, 2020
How Intel’s Work With Autonomous Cars Could Redefine General Purpose AI
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
October 29, 2020
Dell Technologies World: Weaving Together Human And Machine Interaction For AI And Robotics
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
October 23, 2020
The Super Moderator, or How IBM Project Debater Could Save Social Media
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
October 16, 2020
FEATURE | By Cynthia Harvey,
October 07, 2020
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Guest Author,
October 05, 2020
CIOs Discuss the Promise of AI and Data Science
FEATURE | By Guest Author,
September 25, 2020
Microsoft Is Building An AI Product That Could Predict The Future
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
September 25, 2020
Top 10 Machine Learning Companies 2020
FEATURE | By Cynthia Harvey,
September 22, 2020
NVIDIA and ARM: Massively Changing The AI Landscape
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
September 18, 2020
Continuous Intelligence: Expert Discussion [Video and Podcast]
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By James Maguire,
September 14, 2020
Artificial Intelligence: Governance and Ethics [Video]
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By James Maguire,
September 13, 2020
IBM Watson At The US Open: Showcasing The Power Of A Mature Enterprise-Class AI
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
September 11, 2020
Artificial Intelligence: Perception vs. Reality
FEATURE | By James Maguire,
September 09, 2020
Anticipating The Coming Wave Of AI Enhanced PCs
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
September 05, 2020
The Critical Nature Of IBM’s NLP (Natural Language Processing) Effort
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
August 14, 2020
Datamation is the leading industry resource for B2B data professionals and technology buyers. Datamation's focus is on providing insight into the latest trends and innovation in AI, data security, big data, and more, along with in-depth product recommendations and comparisons. More than 1.7M users gain insight and guidance from Datamation every year.
Advertise with TechnologyAdvice on Datamation and our other data and technology-focused platforms.
Advertise with Us
Property of TechnologyAdvice.
© 2025 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved
Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this
site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives
compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products
appear on this site including, for example, the order in which
they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies
or all types of products available in the marketplace.