Don't get me wrong. Each of these features is desirable to someone. But all of them are insignificant in that they won't change how people use their phones. They won’t change human behavior or culture.
Apple's announcement of its Touch ID fingerprint system, however, represents a monumental shift in how we use phones and what we'll use them for.
Here's why Touch ID is giant news and the beginning of something major.
Touch ID features a 500 ppi fingerprint scanner built into the iPhone 5S's Home button. It replaces the passcode to unlock the phone and the Apple ID password for buying stuff on iTunes.
Instead of “swiping,” you just press a finger to the button. The metal ring around the outside registers the presence of a body part, telling the inside to scan your finger. Each time you scan, you improve future accuracy by giving the system a more data on your unique fingerprint patterns.
The idea that Apple can get millions of users to embrace fingerprint scanning sounds unlikely.
People don’t like fingerprint scanning, for three reasons.
First, fingerprint scanning is associated with criminality. For the most past century or so, people charged with crimes had their fingerprints on file somewhere and those never charged didn’t.
Second, we’re living in an age of privacy violation and mistrust, especially now in the wake of the NSA revelations. It’s one thing to feel that one’s emails are being read and phone calls recorded. But fingerprint data make us identifiable in an unknown future. Once those shadowy forces get hold of our fingerprints, they’ll have them forever and into an unknown, possibly dystopian future.
And third, fingerprints on phones is associated with failure and confusion.
Phones have had fingerprint sensors before. The first Motorola Atrix had one. (Motorola took that feature out of the Atrix 2 because hardly anybody used it.)
Toshiba launched its Portege G900 and G500 phones with fingerprint scanners.
Hitachi built one into their W51H phone for the Japanese market.
All these products used AuthenTec fingerprint readers (Apple acquired AuthenTec in July, 2012) and all of them failed in the market.
Historically, fingerprint readers have appeared only on blocky, ugly and obscure phones and installed in weird places, such as on the back of the handset, or under the screen on flip phones.
The readers themselves have been ugly, a slot with two pieces of visible metal across which you were supposed to drag a finger.
It’s purpose often seemed unclear -- usually just to keep others from using your phone.
I think Apple will be able to overcome all of these concerns. By building fingerprint scanning into a mainstream product, Apple will nudge the association of fingerprint scanning away from its criminal association.
Also: Apple claims fingerprint scanning is all handled on the phone and never uploaded outside the phone.
It’s also true that, while it seems like everyone is freaked out about the NSA and other snoops, in fact people will eagerly risk privacy violation to gain convenience.
And finally, Apple’s implementation of fingerprint scanning is actually visually appealing (a smooth sapphire glass case instead of a weird metal slot) and it’s place on the Home button where iPhone users are already used to placing their fingers. No major change in behavior is being asked for.
And its initial purposes are very clear. Apple’s proposition is to eliminate the minor but constant inconveniences of entering the passcode to access the phone and the password to download apps. Almost every 5S user will take advantage of the password feature, eventually representing dozens, then hundreds of millions of users. This will dramatically increase the number of people who have used fingerprint readers on phones by several orders of magnitude and making that technology acceptable on other smartphone platforms as well.
Note that other companies are already working on building more fingerprint readers into phones. For example, the upcoming giant-screen HTC Max phone is rumored to have a fingerprint scanner as well.
And other companies are also working on ways to get rid of the passcode, for example, the Moto X’s ability to bypass the passcode near user-designated “trusted” Bluetooth devices and also when placed near its NFC Skip device.
Bypassing passcodes and passwords will be popular, but by itself not significant. The true significance lies in what comes next.
Photo courtesy of Shutterstock.