The two research firms are usually pretty close in their estimates and this quarter there were only a few significant differences. Gartner reported that worldwide server shipments rose six percent over the same quarter last year to 2.1 million units, while revenue for the same period climbed 4.5 percent to $12.9 billion for the quarter.
IDC projects the market to have grown by 4.9 percent year-over-year to $12.4 billion in the first quarter of 2007, with unit shipments up 4.6 percent. It did not give a unit sales figure.
Where they differ is who is in the lead. IDC puts HP (Quote) in the lead in Q1 of '07 with $3.615 billion in sales and 29.2 percent of the market and IBM (Quote) in second place with $3.579 billion in revenue and 28.9% of the market.
Gartner reverses the positions, with IBM in the lead at $3.832 billion in revenue and 29.8 percent of the market and HP in second place with $3.635 billion and 28.2 percent. This can be chalked up to methodologies for determining sales.
What's not in doubt is HP's execution. That, said Jed Scaramella, research analyst in IDC's enterprise computing group, is excellent. "HP has said they are now focused on not selling technology for technology's sake. They talk about how every piece of technology relates back to the business case for the customer," he told internetnews.com.
HP's strategy of sales is to get away from emphasizing "speeds and feeds," as Scaramella put it, and adopt "consultative selling" to its sales methodology. Every piece of equipment pitched to a customer is presented on the premise of how it will improve their business, lower costs and improve productivity.
IBM did well, particularly with its System z/z Series mainframes, despite the fact that the mainframe has been repeatedly declared dead or dying for almost two decades. Sun is also doing well, growing slightly if not quickly.
The two research firms also differ on where Dell and Sun fit into the mix. IDC has Sun (Quote) in third place, with $1.356 billion in revenue and 10.9 percent of the overall sales, and Dell (Quote) in fourth place with $1.346 billion and 10.9 percent of sales.